Three signs that
all is not well under the developmentalist, consumerist regime that counts as public
policy in Brazil :
the grocery store around the corner
from my apartment was assaulted at 6am Sunday morning. Upset that the
manager didn’t have the code to the safe, the two assailants put something that
“had the appearance of a grenade” in the mouth of the manager and kicked him in
the face. Really? Flamengo is a middle and upper-middle class neighborhood in
the center of town. Perhaps we should require that everyone wear five rings to
work? The assailants escaped out the back of the store and the supermarket
opened for business as usual at 11am.
Sunday brought Vasco
x Flamengo to the Engenhão. On the way to the stadium a bus full of
Flamengo supporters from Resende stopped at a gas station, were put into a rage
after seeing some Vasco fans and started to break everything in sight. They
then chased down, stabbed, shot and killed
30 year old Diego Matins Leal, who wasn’t wearing a Vasco shirt. 57 people were
arrested. As an aside, there were only 19,469 people at the game and only
15,459 of them paid to get in, meaning that 21% of fans entered for free. The
paying fans forked over an average of R$26 per ticket for gate receipts of
R$403,835. Those who aren’t entitled to half-price tickets paid between R$30
and R$60, subsidizing everyone else. Between the latent, bubbling violence of
the torcidas organizadas, the
militarization of stadium space that does nothing to diminish the violence but
treats everyone as a potential criminal, the high cost of tickets, the
difficulty of access and the terrible Engenhão stadium (which I want to say,
again, is no longer called Estádio Olímpico João Havelange, but Stadium Rio
- a fact continuously ignored by the
media here) – is it any wonder that the biggest rivalry in Rio can only get
half the average attendance of
MLS's Seattle Sounders?
And to continue
what has been a very depressing post…In the last week two kids have been killed
by Rio ’s security forces. One,
a 15 year old male, was killed outside his home by BOPE as he bent down to
pick up the keys that his mom had thrown from the upstairs window. Shot three
times, his mother was forced to clean her son’s blood off the doorstep. Yesterday, a four
year old girl was killed by Military Police during a raid. In the USA, people make tragic films about these events. In Rio, this is everyday
news and a sign that not all is well.
It would appear
that the metrics of security for Rio
de Janeiro are indeed linked to the ability of Zona
Sul residents and visitors to walk around with an iphone on their way to get
some frozen yogurt. For those who live outside the Olympic City, there are
daily, deadly reminders that NOTHING FUNDAMENTAL HAS CHANGED. The appearance of
new buildings, shopping malls, museums, ageing football stars and the occasional
international celebrity only mean that there’s a chance for someone to make
money, not that there’s any kind of meaningful wealth redistribution, or shift
in paradigm. To the contrary, the
wholesale capitulation of the Worker’s Party to private industry has
stuffed private hands even further into public pockets. Three absurd deaths in three days, a
supermarket manager getting kicked in the face with a grenade stuffed in his
mouth, endemic and systemic corruption, phantasmagoric mega-projects, the decline of
popular culture and fawning fealty to a posse of high-handed moralists: the narcotic
power of the five rings hides the violence from plain sight.
5 comments:
Wow, bleak stuff. Really discouraging to read about conditions at this derby. Not to mention in your neighborhood.
What I'd like to know is the degree to which Brazilians are waking up to political/media PROPAGANDA.
Are blogs like yours, You Tube, Twitter, Facebook waking the povo up and starting an "arab spring" of sorts or not?
Being Brazilian myself I'm grateful for your insight and I want to know how or if the truth is making the people reconsider their loyalties to politicians and TV Globo?
I'm not sure to what degree Brazilians are "waking up" or reconsider the trusted sources of mis-information. There are some movements working towards presenting reality, but the influence of the "grande midia" is so pervasive, so encrusted into the DNA that there's not much we can do but continue to work for more social justice through writing and activism.
Thank you for the reply.
Dilma is the COVER of Forbes September issue highlighting power women.
http://www.forbes.com/sites/alexisglick/2012/08/22/dilma-rousseff-brazil-entrepreneurs-power-women/
"According to Nielsen, Brazil had 82.4 million Internet users in the first quarter of 2012 compared with 62.3 million three years earlier. On Facebook, Tumblr and Twitter Brazilians are the second most active social network users behind the U.S. "
This doesn't surprise me but I do scratch my head in bewilderment as to why it hasn't been used FOR CHANGE on the major issues of corruption, health, education, infrastructure and of course accountability.
What do you think will be the CATALYST?
Catalysts for change are indeed hard to come by. One would have thought that the robbed elections in the USA in 2000 and 2004 + the financial collapse would have stimul,ated some changes there, but we are seeing the rightward turn of all debate and all parties instead of a call for more solid democratic institutions and greater controls on capital accumulation, etc. In Brazil there will be a crash, yes, but I don't think it will result in a change because people will resign themselves to the immutability of a cultura escravocrata. The very real changes and progress that have been made in Brazil over the last generation cannot be denied, but it is difficult to tell if the increase in purchasing power, provision of electricity, and elimination of hunger are enough to alter the basic pillars of society. Certainly not in 25 years, but perhaps in 100? Brazil's problems are not new, nor will they be solved quickly and it might take 100 million individual ctalysts to make meaningful change. That, in a passive society that is used to getting hit over the head with a baton (or worse, as dilma knows) when oppositional voices are raised, might take some time indeed.
Post a Comment