Sunday was election day. There were no football matches, no selling of alcohol for most of the day, and absolutely no controversy about counting the electronically submitted votes. More than 135 million Brazilians voted. The lower house of the federal government will have representatives from 22 different parties, the senate 15 parties. In Brazil, you have the option to vote for no one. Brilliant. Incredibly, there were many dozens of candidates for federal deputy in the state of Rio that didn't even vote for themselves. Their spouses didn't vote for them, their children didn't vote for them. 0 votes! That's as many as I had! From São Paulo, the USAmerican equivalent of Howdy Doody is going to Brasilia where he will be part of a governing body that includes Brazil's 1994 World Cup wining forwards, Bebeto and Romario. The green party presidential candidate, Marina Silva, managed 20% of the vote, forcing a run off between Coke and Pepsi, or if you prefer, Brahma and Skol. There will be no surprises from here on as Lula has fluffed the pillow of his cult of personality enough to ensre that Dilma will have a comfy place to lay her Gorgon-like head.
In so far as any of this has to do with the general trajectory of my reporting, nothing much changed on Sunday, but there were some small victories. Eurico Miranda, the man who stole millions from Vasco da Gama and put the team into financial ruin and the second division, did not get elected. His successor, Roberto Dinamite (a former national team player and Vasco idol), did - though I'm not sure if that is good news or just of passing interest. Rio's former mayor, Cesar Maia, only won 11% in his bid for the Senate. Now that we're all on the way to a system of urban, environmental, and social governance that thinks of return on investment first and fufilling social contracts tenth, Maia's neo-liberal interventions are no longer needed anyway. Maybe Rio 2016 will hire him to do something.
One of the people I discuss in Temples of the Earthbound Gods, Chiquinho da Mangueira, the former head of SUDERJ, got himself elected as a state deputy just ahead of Dinamite. Chiquino abused the image of the Maracanã in his electoral campaign more than any candidate EVER. You'd think he'd built the place himself not presided over the distrouous 2005-2007 reforms.
Did any candidate for any office at any level of government at any time during the campaign season make any comments criticizing the current craze of coughing up currency for constructing colossal and short lived mega-events? Possibly. Unlikely.
Does the voting system work in Brazil? Yes.
Is voting part of participatory democracy? Yes.
Is is sufficient? No.
I had an accidental lunch with a taxi driver today. As he sat down, he commented that the restaurant was without water. He was irate because the owner of the restaurant was so blithe about the situation. The whole neighborhood was without water, e dai? Did anyone complain? Mabye. Was there anyone listening if they did? Probably not. The taxi driver then explained how much he had to pay in taxes to drive his taxi. It was such an absurd number that I shot a black bean from my mouth into my nasal passage. Then he told me how much the flanelinhas were charging to park in Niteroi: R$20. (Fanelinhas are guys who stand on the street and "help" you park.) If you don't pay what they want, you come back and your windows are broken or your tires slashed. Lovely. R$20 is no joke to park on a street that should be free, or have a meter or have some kind of regulated system. Does anyone complain? Yes. Does the problem get addressed? Yes. In the Zona Sul of Rio. Sometimes. He told me he was with a judge one day who never paid the flanelinha, he simply parked and walked away. If something happened, he called some cops on the phone and had them arrest all of the flanelinhas in sight. It's good to be the king.
The point of all this? Democracy is not and should not be limited to the act of voting. Brazilians pay insanely high taxes for the insanely shoddy delivery of public services. The World Cup and Olympics are inherently anti-democratic events, run by anti-democratic institutions, supported by democratically elected individuals, and financed with public money, lots of it. These events and people and institutions are combining to worsen the conditions of Brazilian democracy. There is already a general sense of helplessness in the face of an impossibly complex bureaucracy that simply does not deliver what it should given the amount of money shoveled into it. When FIFA and the IOC come to town, abre a boca Galvão.
At the same time, the voting machines work. There are dozens of political parties. Political discourse is not driven by hatred of immigrants or religious groups or about which party is going to fortify the border with 15,000 or 45,000 more troops. 135 million votes in a country of 190 million is impressive, even though it's a legal requirement. People discuss their political ideas openly in the streets and aren't afraid to have friends with different political views. As with democracy, as with flamenguistas, ninguém perfeito.
06 October 2010
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Labels
2014 World Cup
Rio de Janeiro
Maracanã
FIFA
2016 Olympics
2016 Summer Olympics
Eduardo Paes
CBF
Copa do Mundo 2014
Rio de Janeiro Olympics
Ricardo Texeira
World Cup 2014
Vasco da Gama
2010 World Cup
White Elephants
mega-events
APO
UPP
BRT
Brazil football
Flamengo
Lula
Orlando Silva
violence
ANT
Aldeia Maracana
Carlos Nuzman
Dilma
Eike Batista
Rio 2016
Sergio Cabral
2007 Pan American Games
Campeonato Carioca
Corruption
IOC
Jerome Valcke
Novo Maracanã
stadiums
BOPE
BRASIL 2016
Brasil 2014
Engenhao
Joao Havelange
Maracana
Policia Militar
Vila Autódromo
Aldo Rebelo
Botafogo
Henrique Meirelles
Medida Provisoria
Metro
Revolta do Vinagre
Sao Paulo
Sepp Blatter
World Cup 2010
forced removal
Carnaval
Elefantes Brancos
Fechadao
Marcia Lins
Minerao
Morumbi
Odebrecht
Porto Maravilha
Rio+20
Romario
Security Walls
South Africa
South Africa 2010
TCU
Transoeste
protests
public money
public transportation
slavery
transparency
x-Maracana
Andrew Jennings
Argentina
Audiencia Publica
Barcelona
Brazil
Carvalho Hosken
Comitê Popular
Confederatons Cup
Copa do Brasil 2010
Cost overruns
Crisis of Capital Accumulation
EMOP
FERJ
Favela do Metro
Fluminense
Fluminese
Fonte Novo
IMX
Jose Marin
Leonel Messi
London 2012
Marcelo Freixo
Maré
Museu do Indio
Olympic Delivery Authority
Perimetral
Rocinha
Soccerex
Transcarioca
bicycles
consumer society
debt
idiocy
militarization
transportation
1995 Rugby World Cup
2004 Olympics
2015 Copa America
Banco Imobiliario
Barcas SA
Belo Horizonte
Bom Senso F.C.
Brasilerao
CDURP
CONMEBOL
Champions League. Mourinho
Complexo do Alemão
Copa Libertadores
Cupula dos Povos
ESPN
England
FiFA Fan Fest
Istanbul 2020
Jogos Militares
John Carioca
Kaka
Manaus
McDonald's
Obama
Olympic Village
PPP
Paralympics
Providencia
Recife
Russia
Salvador
Soccer City
Taksim Square
Tatu-bola
Urban Social Forum
Vidigal
Vila Olimpica
War
World Cup
Xaracana
attendance figures
cities
corrupcao
drugs
estadios
football
frangueiro
futebol
mafia
planejamento urbano
police repression
porn
privitization
reforms
shock doctrine
taxes
201
2010 Elections
2010 Vancouver Olypmics
2013
2018 World Cup
2030 Argentina / Uruguay
ABRAJI
AGENCO
ANPUR
ANT-SP
Amazonia
Ancelmo Gois
Andrade Gutierrez
Anthony Garotinho
Arena Amazonia
Arena Pernambucana
Athens
Atlético Paranaense
Avenida das Americas
BID
Barra de Tijuca
Blatter
Brasil x Cote d'Iviore
Brasileirão 2013
Brasilia
Brasilierao
Bruno Souza
Bus fares
COB
COI
COMLURB
CPI
CPO
Cabral
Caixa Economica
Canal do Anil
Cantagalo
Celio de Barros
Cesar Maia
Chapeu Mangueira
Chile 2015
Choque do Ordem
Cidade da Copa
Class One Powerboat Racing
Clint Dempsey
Comite
Companhia das Docas
Copa do Brasil
Corinthians
Cuiabá
Curitiba
Dave Zrin
David Harvey
Der Spiegel
Eastwood
Edge of Sports
Escola Friendenrich
Expo Estadio
Expo Urbano
FGV
Fonte Nova
Gamboa
Garotinho
Geostadia
Ghana
Globo
Greek Debt Crisis
Greek Olympics
HBO
Hipoptopoma
IMG
IPHAN
ISL
Iniesta
Internatinal Football Arena
Invictus
Istanbul
Itaquerao
Jacque Rogge
Jefferson
John Coates
Jose Beltrame
Julio Grondona
Julio Lopes
Julio de Lamare
Knights Templar
Korea
Lei Geral da Copa
MAR
MEX
Manchester United
Mangabeira Unger
Maracanã. Soccerex
Marina da Gloria
Mexico
Milton Santos
Molotov Cocktail
Mr.Balls
Neymar
Nicholas Leoz
Nilton Santos
Olympic Flag
Olympic Park Project
Oscar Niemeyer
Pacaembu
Pan American Games
Parque Olimpico
Pernambuco
Plano Popular
Plano Popular do Maracana
Plano Popular do Maracanã
Play the Game
Pope
Porto Alegre
Porto Olimpico
Porto Seguro
Portuguesa
Praca Tiradentes
Preview
Projeto Morrinho
Putin
Qatar
Quatar 2022
RSA
Realengo
Regis Fichtner
Roberto Dinamite
Russia 2018
SETRANS
SMH
Santa Teresa
Santos
Sao Raimundo
Sargento Pepper
Security Cameras
Smart City
Sochi 2014
South Korea
Stormtroopers
São Januário
São Paulo
Teargas
Templars
Tokyo 2020
Tropa do Elite II
Turkey
UFRJ/IPPUR
URU
USA
USA!
Unidos da Tijuca
United States government
Urban Age Conference
VVIP
Via Binário
Victory Team
Vila Autodromo
Vila Cruzeiro
Vila do Pan
Vilvadao
Vivaldao
Volta Alice
Wasteland
Workers' Party
World Cup 2018
Xavi
Zurich
apartments
atrazos
barrier
beer
bio-fuels
bonde
capacities
civil society
comite popular
copa sudamericana
crack
crime
dengue
dictatorship
estádios
favelalógica
feira livre
fiador
flooding
freedom of information
furos
geral
graffiti
guarda municipal
host city agreement
identity
infrastructure
ipanema
istoe
labor
rape
riots
schedule
school shooting
security
segregation
social movements
stadium
state of exception
supervia
tear gas
ticket prices
torcidas organizadas
tourism
traffic
tragedy
trash
trem-bala
velodromo
wikileaks
xingar
2 comments:
Good post except for the low blow directed at Flamengo.
no problem with Flamengo, its the menguistas! rs
Post a Comment